Best Cigars for Beginners: Where to Start
- Noman Tahir
- May 24
- 2 min read
Best Cigars for Beginners: Where to Start
The first cigar you smoke matters. Start with something too strong and you'll get dizzy, chalk it up as "not for you," and miss out on one of life's great pleasures. Start with the right cigar — mild, balanced, smooth — and you'll understand immediately why people collect them, talk about them, and smoke them for decades.
What to Look for in a Beginner Cigar
Mild-to-medium body: Body refers to the strength and intensity of the smoke. For beginners, mild to medium is the target. Full-bodied cigars can cause dizziness in smokers who haven't built nicotine tolerance.
Natural or Connecticut wrapper: Connecticut shade wrappers are light golden-tan in color and produce a creamy, mild, sweet smoke. Colorado (medium brown, natural) wrappers are a step up in strength but still approachable.
Size: For a first cigar, a Robusto (5" x 50 ring gauge) or Corona (5.5" x 42–44 ring gauge) is ideal. Long enough to develop flavor, short enough not to overwhelm.
Our Top 7 Beginner Cigars
1. Arturo Fuente Hemingway Short Story
Body: Mild-Medium | Wrapper: Natural Cameroon | Price: ~$10–12. The perfect first cigar. Small, beautifully made, with a gentle earthy-sweet character. The Fuente Hemingway Short Story is a perfecto shape that's been a "gateway cigar" for thousands of enthusiasts.
2. Montecristo White
Body: Mild | Wrapper: Connecticut Shade | Price: ~$8–10. Montecristo White is about as smooth as a premium cigar gets. The Connecticut shade wrapper delivers cream, cedar, and gentle spice in a package that won't overwhelm new palates.
3. ACID Blondie
Body: Mild | Wrapper: Infused Connecticut | Price: ~$7–9. If you want to ease in with something sweet and aromatic, ACID Blondie is the entry point. Infused with botanicals and herbs, it's mild, sweet, and very approachable. Excellent for social settings.
4. Cohiba Red Dot Robusto
Body: Mild-Medium | Wrapper: Connecticut Shade | Price: ~$8–12. The US Cohiba is a mild, consistent cigar that's widely available and well-constructed. The Red Dot Robusto is a reliable, unfussy choice for a first smoke.
5. Davidoff Signature 2000
Body: Mild | Wrapper: Connecticut Shade | Price: ~$18–22. If you want to start with something truly world-class, the Davidoff Signature line is impeccably made. The construction, draw, and finish are flawless.
6. Padron 2000 Natural
Body: Medium | Wrapper: Natural Nicaraguan | Price: ~$9–11. The most affordable Padron in the lineup. The 2000 Natural is a medium-bodied Nicaraguan puro that punches well above its price point.
7. Oliva Serie O Robusto
Body: Medium | Wrapper: Natural Nicaraguan Habano | Price: ~$8–10. Oliva's entry-level offering is exceptional for the price. Good construction, clean burn, and a medium-body that hints at the more complex Serie V without overwhelming beginners.
Beginner Tips
Cut correctly: Use a guillotine cutter and cut just inside the cap line — about 1/16" from the closed end. Don't cut too deep.
Light with butane: Use a butane torch lighter, not a regular gasoline lighter. Gasoline lighters impart a chemical taste.
Don't inhale: Unlike cigarettes, cigar smoke is not meant to be inhaled. Draw the smoke into your mouth, hold for a moment, and release.
Go slow: A good cigar should last 45–90 minutes. Don't rush it. Take a puff every minute or so.
