Short answer: a cigar ashtray needs a deep bowl and a wide stirrup. Cigarette ashtrays are too shallow to hold the ash of a toro and too narrow to rest one without crushing the wrapper.
Cigar ashtray vs. cigarette ashtray
The difference is scale. A cigarette is thin and finishes in minutes; a premium cigar can be twice as thick and burn for an hour or more, so it needs a bigger rest, a deeper bowl and a heavier base. A cigarette ashtray's narrow notches pinch a thick wrapper, and its shallow dish fills quickly with cigar ash. A cigar ashtray is built around the cigar: a wide, rounded stirrup that supports it near the band, a bowl deep enough to hold a full session's ash, and enough weight to stay put when you set a cigar down.
What makes a good one
- A deep bowl. A cigar produces far more ash than a cigarette, and ash left in the bowl keeps the room smelling stale.
- A wide stirrup. The rest should cradle a 50–60 ring gauge without pinching. Narrow grooves crack wrappers.
- Weight. Ceramic, crystal or stone stays put. Light metal slides.
- Enough rests. Two for company, four for the lounge.
Also look at where the rests sit. A rest that holds the cigar level, or with the lit end slightly over the bowl, lets ash fall into the dish rather than onto the table. A smooth, glazed or polished rest is kinder to the wrapper than a rough edge.
Materials
Ceramic and crystal are the common choices and both clean easily. Stone and concrete are heavy and durable. Melamine travels well for outdoor use.
| Material | Strengths | Watch for |
|---|---|---|
| Ceramic | Heavy, glazed surface wipes clean, wide range of designs | Can chip or crack if dropped |
| Crystal or glass | Heavy, easy to see when it needs emptying | Shows residue and fingerprints; breakable |
| Metal | Durable, modern finishes | Lighter pieces slide; some finishes are hand wash only |
| Stone or concrete | Very heavy and stable outdoors | Porous surfaces can hold odor if not sealed |
| Polyresin or melamine | Light, weather tolerant, good for patios and travel | Lighter weight in wind |
Ashtrays we carry
A few pieces from our cigar ashtrays collection, by how you smoke:
- For the patio or a group: the Arturo Fuente Hands of Time Ashtray, a round gloss ceramic piece with rests for up to four cigars, and the Arturo Fuente XL Cream Ashtray, a 12-inch ceramic tray that also holds four.
- For the desk or lounge chair: the Colibri Heritage Cube Ashtray, with four rests built into the rim and a deep ash pocket, and the Colibri Quasar Round Ashtray, a 7-inch round tray with multiple rests.
- For outdoors: the Craftsman's Bench Boca Grande Ashtray, a polyresin tray shaped like a tobacco leaf with a rest at each end, which J.C. Newman tests for outdoor settings.
Our cigar ashtrays compared
| Ashtray | Material or finish | Size | Cigar rests | Where it fits |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arturo Fuente Hands of Time | Gloss ceramic | About 8½ to 9 in across, 2¾ in high | Up to 4 | Patio table or home bar |
| Arturo Fuente XL Cream | Ceramic | 12 in across, 2½ in high | 4 | A full table or lounge corner |
| Colibri Heritage Cube | Matte metallic finish | 5.9 x 5.9 x 3.5 in, about 2.5 lb | 4, widened for any ring gauge | Desk, lounge or a breezy patio |
| Colibri Quasar Round | Faceted Quasar pattern | 7 in across, 2 in high, 1.3 lb | Several | Desk or side table |
| Craftsman’s Bench Boca Grande | Polyresin | 11⅝ x 6⅜ x 2½ in | 2, one at each end | Outdoors |
What size cigar ashtray do you need?
Size it to the number of people smoking and the cigars they smoke. For one or two people at a desk, a tray of about 6 to 7 inches with wide rests, such as the Colibri Heritage Cube or Quasar Round, is enough. For four around a patio table, a ceramic tray of roughly 9 to 12 inches with four rests, like the Fuente pieces, gives everyone a place to set a cigar down. Check the rests against the ring gauge you smoke: a 60-ring gordo needs a wider cradle than a 42-ring corona.
Indoor vs. outdoor ashtrays
Indoors, weight and a deep bowl matter most, because the goal is to contain ash and odor. Outdoors, wind is the problem. A deep ash pocket keeps ash from blowing across the table, and a heavier tray stays put on a breezy patio. Weather-tolerant materials such as polyresin handle sun and the occasional rain better than glazed ceramic left outside year-round.
Ash etiquette
Let the ash build to about an inch. It insulates the ember and keeps the burn cool. Tap gently rather than stubbing, and lay the cigar down to go out on its own rather than crushing it — crushing is what makes a room smell bad.
When you set a cigar down mid-smoke, rest it in the stirrup rather than leaning it against the rim, and give it a slow draw within a minute or two so it stays lit. If it goes out, that is normal; relight it by toasting the foot again. Our guide to how to light a cigar covers relighting, and how to smoke a cigar covers the rest.
What do you do with a finished cigar?
Leave it in the rest or the bowl to go out on its own. Once it is cold, discard it in a covered outdoor bin rather than leaving it in the ashtray overnight, since spent cigar ends are what make a room smell stale. Do not drop a cigar that is still smoldering into a trash can.
How to clean a cigar ashtray
- Empty it after every session. Cold ash and spent cigar ends are the main source of stale smell.
- Wash with warm water and mild soap. A soft brush reaches the rests and corners.
- Follow the maker's care note. Several metal and finished pieces, including Colibri's, are hand wash only.
- Dry fully before using it again. Wet ash sticks and is harder to clean next time.
Is a cigar ashtray a good gift?
It is an easy accessory gift because it suits whatever cigar the person smokes. For a Fuente collector, both Arturo Fuente ashtrays carry Fuente family artwork, and the XL Cream arrives in a custom gift box; pair one with a few Opus X Lost City cigars or a pick from our Opus X cigars. The Colibri Heritage Cube comes in a gift box with a two-year warranty. More ideas are in our cigar accessory gifts.
Shop
Shop every ashtray we carry in our cigar ashtrays collection, including Prometheus and Opus X pieces, or browse all cigar accessories.
No ashtray on the golf course or the boat? The Get a Grip cigar clip holds a lit cigar on a cart, rail or table edge without tearing the wrapper.
An ashtray pairs naturally with a cigar lighter and a cigar cutter, and a cigar case covers the trip to the patio or the course.
$9.99 flat shipping, free on orders of $125 or more; in-stock orders ship within 1–2 business days from Yuma, Arizona.
Frequently asked questions
Can you use a regular ashtray for a cigar?
You can, but most cigarette ashtrays are too shallow for cigar ash and their narrow rests pinch the wrapper. A cigar ashtray has a deeper bowl and wider rests.
How long should cigar ash get before you tap it off?
About an inch. A firm ash insulates the ember and keeps the burn cool. Tap it gently into the ashtray rather than flicking it.
How do you put out a cigar?
Rest it in the ashtray and let it go out on its own. Crushing or stubbing a cigar releases more smoke and odor.
What material should a cigar ashtray be made of?
Ceramic, crystal and stone are heavy and stay put indoors. Polyresin and melamine are lighter and handle outdoor use well.
How often should you clean a cigar ashtray?
Empty it after every session and wash it with warm water and mild soap regularly. Check the care note, since some metal pieces are hand wash only.
How many rests should a cigar ashtray have?
One for each person smoking at the same time: two for a pair, four for a group or the lounge. Each rest should cradle a 50 to 60 ring gauge without pinching the wrapper.
What size cigar ashtray do I need?
About 6 to 7 inches across for one or two smokers at a desk, and roughly 9 to 12 inches with four rests for a group around a table.
What kind of ashtray works outdoors?
A heavy tray or one with a deep ash pocket, in a weather-tolerant material such as polyresin. J.C. Newman tests the Craftsman’s Bench Boca Grande for outdoor use, and the Colibri Heritage Cube’s deep pocket keeps ash in place in a breeze.
Where can I buy a cigar ashtray in Yuma, AZ?
At Sun of a Gun Cigars & Spirits, 1651 S Arizona Ave in Yuma, or online in our cigar ashtrays collection.




