Sun of a Gun Cigars & Spirits
My Father The Judge
The Judge is the My Father Cigars line released in 2016, eight years after the first My Father blend. My Father calls it full bodied and says it was inspired by a friend of the García family; Cigar Aficionado reported in September 2016 that the friend is a judge. It is made at My Father Cigars S.A. in Estelí, Nicaragua: a dark brown Ecuadorian Sumatra Oscuro wrapper over a double binder of Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo, and three Nicaraguan fillers from the family's La Bonita Two, El Pedrero and San Rafael farms. The box label is recreated from an antique 1905 Victorian lithograph.
Filters
4 products
About My Father The Judge
Cigar Aficionado named the Grand Robusto its No. 1 Cigar of 2024 at 98 points, the García family's third Cigar of the Year after Flor de las Antillas in 2012 and Le Bijou 1922 in 2015. The same size had placed No. 7 in the magazine's Top 25 for 2017 and No. 17 for 2021, both at 93 points.
The Judge sizes
| Cigar | Dimensions | Shape | Latest rating |
|---|---|---|---|
| Grand Robusto | 5 x 60 | Box-pressed | 98 points, Cigar Aficionado's No. 1 Cigar of 2024 (medium-full) |
| Toro Box Pressed | 6 x 56 | Box-pressed | 90 points, Cigar Insider, February 2017 (medium-full) |
| Toro Fino | 6 x 52 | Box-pressed, added in 2017 | 89 points, Cigar Insider, March 2018 (medium-full) |
| Corona Gorda | 5⅝ x 46 | Not box-pressed, added in 2020 | 87 points, Cigar Aficionado, October 2020 (full) |
We sell every size as a single, a 5-pack or a box of 20.
The Judge prices
Prices and availability update automatically from our inventory.
| Cigar | Price | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| My Father The Judge Grand Robusto Box Pressed | Single $13.99 5-Pack $63.95 Box of 20 $235.80 |
In stock |
| My Father The Judge Toro Box Pressed | Single $13.99 5-Pack $63.95 Box of 20 $237.80 |
In stock |
| My Father The Judge Toro Fino | Single $12.99 5-Pack $58.95 Box of 20 $218.80 |
In stock |
| My Father The Judge Corona Gorda | Single $12.99 5-Pack $58.95 Box of 20 $218.80 |
In stock |
What to pour with The Judge
My Father's page for the line suggests no pairing, so these are our house suggestions. From our bar, a caramel-forward bourbon or a rye; after dinner, a sherry-cask Scotch such as the Macallan 12 Year Sherry Oak. More in the bourbon and cigar pairing guide.
What a Sumatra wrapper is
Sumatra-seed tobacco takes its name from the Indonesian island where the variety was first grown for cigar wrapper. Today much of the Sumatra-seed wrapper in premium cigars is grown in Ecuador, often under the region's natural cloud cover, and it runs from medium brown to the dark Sumatra Oscuro that The Judge wears. Smokers usually describe Sumatra leaf as earthy and spicy, with a slightly toothy texture.
On The Judge, My Father sets that dark brown Ecuadorian Sumatra Oscuro over a double binder of Nicaraguan Corojo and Criollo and three Nicaraguan fillers from the family's La Bonita Two, El Pedrero and San Rafael farms. My Father calls the result full bodied, so newer smokers may want to start lighter; our beginner's guide suggests where.
Choosing a size. The Grand Robusto is short and very wide at 5 x 60; the Toro Box Pressed (6 x 56) and Toro Fino (6 x 52) add length; the Corona Gorda (5⅝ x 46) is the slim, round option.
Popular picks
- My Father The Judge Grand Robusto Box Pressed — 5 x 60; Cigar Aficionado's No. 1 Cigar of 2024
- My Father The Judge Toro Box Pressed — 6 x 56, box-pressed
- My Father The Judge Toro Fino — 6 x 52, box-pressed
- My Father The Judge Corona Gorda — 5⅝ x 46, round
- My Father Le Bijou 1922 Box Pressed Torpedo — 6⅛ x 52; Cigar Aficionado's No. 1 Cigar of 2015
- My Father Flor de las Antillas Toro — 6 x 52; Cigar Aficionado's 2012 Cigar of the Year, 96 points
The first four are The Judge. The last two complete the García family's three Cigars of the Year: see Le Bijou 1922 or more Sumatra-wrapped cigars.
Common questions
How strong is The Judge? My Father calls it full bodied. Cigar Aficionado and Cigar Insider have rated the Grand Robusto, the Toro Box Pressed and the Toro Fino medium-full, and Cigar Aficionado rated the Corona Gorda full.
Which Judge sizes are box-pressed? Three of the four: the Grand Robusto, the Toro Box Pressed and the Toro Fino. The Corona Gorda is not box-pressed.
Did The Judge win Cigar of the Year? Yes. Cigar Aficionado named the Grand Robusto its No. 1 Cigar of 2024 with 98 points.
Who is The Judge named for? My Father says the line was inspired by a friend of the García family, and Cigar Aficionado reported in 2016 that the friend is a judge.
How much is The Judge? Singles run $12.99 (Corona Gorda) to $13.99 (Toro Box Pressed), and boxes $218.80 to $237.80. Current prices for every size in stock are in the price table above.
What is a Sumatra Oscuro wrapper? A dark Sumatra-seed leaf; on The Judge it is grown in Ecuador. Oscuro is one of the darkest wrapper colors.
Which My Father cigars have been Cigar Aficionado's Cigar of the Year? Three: Flor de las Antillas in 2012, the Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Pressed in 2015 and The Judge Grand Robusto in 2024. All three are in this list of picks.
Where can I buy My Father The Judge in Yuma, AZ? At Sun of a Gun Cigars & Spirits, 1651 S Arizona Ave, an official J.C. Newman Diamond Crown Cigar Lounge with a walk-in humidor and a full bar. Call 928-276-3500 to check a size before you visit, or order here. Every order ships with a Boveda humidity pack. In-stock orders ship within 1–2 business days.
How should I store The Judge? Keep the cigars in a humidor at about 65 to 70 percent relative humidity, away from heat; our cigar storage guide has more.
Can I buy a single or a box? Yes. Every size is sold as a single, a 5-pack or a box of 20. $9.99 flat shipping, free on orders of $125 or more.
See all the García lines on our My Father cigars page, more pressed shapes at Box-Pressed Cigars, or read our My Father buying guide.








